Yeah. Harding knew about River Dog (Tess said he said to get the healing stones from River Dog in "Destiny"), but that doesn't necessarily mean he's the Nasedo River Dog knew. And I'll need to come up with a "why" on Atherton's death. Atherton's body was left, and that seems more Harding's style. On the other hand, River Dog was close enough to be a witness, so escape might have been more important than disposing on the body. On the third hand, I'd think Harding would just kill the kid witness, too (provided he was the only one). Which brings up the issue of why Atherton's body was unidentified - River Dog knew who he was, right? Did he have a reason for not telling the police or is just a continuity issue?I have always believed that Ed Harding and TicTac were different people, and it is not clear which one was Nasedo. It was never clearly explained on the show
Oh definitely. He savored freaking out Liz, and then there was the gas station incident. He's a weird one.But Ed is definately not low key. He has left a trail of bodies all over the southwest, as Hubble says. Tess also mentions that they have been hunted for years by the Special Unit. How could that happen, unless Ed was doing stuff to lead the Specail Unit to them?
Ed seems to be a loose cannon. He is cocky, acts creepy and seems to enjoy scaring the kids, leaving mysterious alien symbols and taking Liz, and he challenges the Sheriff and Max. Why wouldn't he just tell them who he is when he came to town?
Do you have an opinion on Harding v. TicTac for the symbol in the woods or flaming symbol? I can't find a logical explanation for that for either of them. And there's the photo of the kids there, too. Did he not know who they were before? Not sure. I sort of lean towards TicTac, just based on timing, and say Harding didn't come to Roswell until later.
Off to read that now.There is more about this on my website too if you are interested - http://www.roswelloracle.com/theoriesshapeshifter.html